Best Pizza in Atlanta ITP

Atlanta's pizza scene has come a long way. You can now get legitimate Neapolitan, proper New York-style slices, Detroit-style pan pizza, and creative pies that don't fit into any category. All inside the perimeter.

This list covers the pizza places that are actually worth driving across town for. Not chains, not franchises. These are independent spots run by people who care about dough, sauce, and cheese in that order.

1

Antico Pizza Napoletana

West Midtown

The place that put Atlanta on the pizza map. Giovanni Di Palma's wood-fired Neapolitan pies are the real deal, made with imported Italian ingredients and cooked at 900 degrees.

  • The San Gennaro (sausage, peppers, onions) is outstanding
  • Communal seating and BYOB policy (no corkage fee) make it a great group spot

Bring a bottle of wine and you've got a very affordable dinner at one of the best pizza places in the Southeast.

Local tip: It's BYOB with no corkage fee. Bring a bottle of wine and you've got a very affordable dinner at one of the best pizza places in the Southeast.
2

Ammazza

Old Fourth Ward

Neapolitan-style pizza in Old Fourth Ward with a 72-hour fermented dough and a massive wood-fired oven. The margherita is a thing of beauty, simple and perfectly charred.

  • Rooftop patio overlooks the neighborhood
  • No reservations, so put your name in on weekends and walk the BeltLine while you wait
  • The dough is the star here
Local tip: No reservations. On weekends, put your name in and walk the BeltLine for 30 minutes while you wait.
3

O4W Pizza

Old Fourth Ward

New York-style slices and whole pies in a casual counter-service spot. The slices are big, foldable, and properly greasy in the best way.

  • Pepperoni slice is a go-to for a reason
  • The white pizza with ricotta is an underrated pick
  • They also do a mean calzone

Two slices and a beer is the perfect quick lunch.

Local tip: Grab two slices and a beer for a quick, satisfying lunch. The white pizza with ricotta is an underrated pick.
4

Slim & Husky's

Summerhill

Creative, thick-crust pizzas with interesting topping combinations in a hip-hop-themed space. Started in Nashville and the Atlanta location delivers.

  • Dough is made fresh daily
  • Specialty pies like the Cee-Lo Green (with pesto) are worth trying
  • Build your own if the specialty pies feel too adventurous. The crust is the star, so keep toppings simple.
Local tip: Build your own if the specialty pies feel too adventurous. The crust is the star here, so keep the toppings simple.
5

Junior's Pizza

West End

A late-night staple near the West End. New York-style slices that are perfect at 1am (and just as good at noon). Nothing fancy, just solid pizza at a fair price.

  • The cheese slice is all you need
  • Open late, making it your go-to post-bar pizza destination
  • The kind of slice shop every neighborhood needs.
Local tip: Open late. This is your post-bar pizza destination. The cheese slice is all you need.
6

Varuni Napoli

Midtown

Certified Neapolitan pizza in Midtown using imported Italian ingredients and a custom-built oven. The dough recipe produces a beautifully blistered crust.

  • Margherita DOC with buffalo mozzarella is the way to go
  • Lunch special is an excellent value (personal pizza and a drink for well under $15)
  • The certification is real. This is as close to Naples as you'll get in Atlanta.
Local tip: The lunch special is an excellent value. Get a personal pizza and a drink for well under $15.
7

Nina & Rafi

Poncey-Highland

A newer spot in Poncey-Highland doing creative neo-Neapolitan pies. The dough is excellent and the toppings are thoughtful. A date-night pizza spot done right.

  • The fungi pizza with mixed mushrooms and truffle oil is worth the upcharge
  • Natural wine list pairs perfectly with any pie
  • Intimate space with a polished but relaxed feel
Local tip: The fungi pizza with mixed mushrooms and truffle oil is worth the upcharge. Pair it with something from the natural wine list.
8

Edgewood Pizza

Old Fourth Ward

A no-frills slice shop on Edgewood Avenue that's been feeding the late-night crowd for years. The slices are huge and the prices are right.

  • Open very late on weekends
  • The pepperoni slice at 2am hits different
  • Exactly the kind of pizza you want after a night out on Edgewood
Local tip: Open very late on weekends. The pepperoni slice at 2am hits different.
9

Little Bear

Summerhill

A Summerhill restaurant that does excellent wood-fired pizzas among other things. The menu is broader than just pizza, but the pies are consistently great.

  • Split a pizza and a few small plates for the best experience
  • The burrata appetizer pairs perfectly with any pie
  • Cocktails are strong and the space is warm and inviting
Local tip: Split a pizza and a few small plates for the best experience. The burrata appetizer pairs perfectly with any pie.
10

Fred's Pizza

Decatur

A Decatur institution doing New York-style pizza since the '80s. The decor hasn't changed in decades, and the pizza is exactly as good as it's always been.

  • Cash only (ATM next door)
  • The large cheese pizza is the move for groups
  • A true original in a sea of newcomers. No frills, no gimmicks, just pizza.
Local tip: Cash only. There's an ATM next door. The large cheese pizza is the move for groups.
‹ All lists